Vinyl Vs Cd Quality Science

They sound different and that s exactly the point.

Vinyl vs cd quality science.

Cd quality sits somewhere in the middle with 44 100 samples per second at 16 bit accuracy. This is an interesting comparison since in the phil collins case the vinyl would appear to have an advantage being an original analog master while in the spyro gyra case the cd would seem to have the advantage since its an original digital master. Schouhamer immink a former philips engineer in the netherlands who was a member of. And a cd s digital storage method means the high and low frequencies don t need to be tweaked as they are on vinyl.

Cd players because they use super accurate digital buffers are immune to this. From a technical standpoint digital cd audio quality is clearly superior to vinyl. There is less interference from hissing turntable rumble etc better stereo channel separation and have no variation in playback speed. As long as you can measure the difference the cd will be better than the vinyl absolutely says kees a.

Cds have a better signal to noise ratio i e. Vinyl is great but the idea that its sound quality is superior to that of uncompressed digital recordings is preposterous. A vinyl record is an analog recording and cds and dvds are digital recordings. On a cd the separation between the left and right channels used in recording is over 90 db.

It wasn t long before vinyl recordings of the same content often had better sound quality at normal listening volumes simply because they had higher dynamic range. Maybe it was coincidence but vinyl began its resurgence at around the same time as recordings started this trend. The cd always comes up technically better if you measure it with scientific. Take a look at the graph below.

What vinyl can t do. And in some cases the depth of field the depth of sound that people talk about enjoying about vinyl that they say is missing from the cd may in fact be a result of the compression to make. Playback and inconsistencies though cd s sample rate is high and we re all well aware how good they sound the idea of its being converted once into digital and then back to analogue losing and approximating information seems to infer it will always be inferior to vinyl.