Vinyl Vs Cement Durability Against Hail

Figure on 20 squares and 5 000 to 10 000 in labor for a typical 2 300 square foot house.

Vinyl vs cement durability against hail.

Fiber cement offers minimal energy savings at 15 r value but can be installed with fanfold or insulating sheathing products to improve the r value of the whole siding system. Hardie board is a fiber cement board made from sand cement and wood fibers that was introduced in the 1980s as an alternative to vinyl siding. A blend of cement sand and cellulose fiber cement offers the look of masonry stucco or wood at a lower cost which can be comparable to vinyl in some cases. Weigh the look you like against upkeep and cost.

It is made from pvc which makes it extremely durable. Fiber cement siding is truly as low maintenance as many homeowner desire. By contrast james hardie fiber cement siding is more durable and up to 5x thicker than vinyl siding. Both materials hold up remarkably well to insects or animals.

Stucco cost plus pros cons 2020. Homeadvisor s siding comparison guide explores the differences pros and cons of fiber cement and vinyl including information on james hardie s hardie board hardiplank fiber cement. Today it is the single most popular siding material for homes in the united states. From vinyl siding to fiber cement we ll help you choose the right siding option for your home.

The lp smartside engineered wood siding showed no signs of impact after being hit with 1 75 inch hail at 81 miles per hour. Hail of 1 25 inch diameter punched through vinyl siding at 57 miles per hour while fiber cement was dented with 1 75 inch diameter hailstones fired at 74 miles per hour. It can be damaged by wind debris hail or any number of other external forces and may crack buckle and warp with changing temperatures. Prices listed are per square 100 square feet.

According to the rsmeans 2014 residential cost data report the installed cost of vinyl siding is on average 201 per 100 square feet while fiber cement totals 300 for the same area. Like vinyl it s very durable. In fact fiber cement siding is so durable and low maintenance that when compared to the time and money most people put into their siding materials and maintenance over the years it practically pays for itself. As there are more elements outside than wind and hail let s revisit the durability factor.

Compare costs easy of installation colors painting options durability thickness r value length of life and more to decide which is the best siding for your home. It is a lot more durable than lightweight vinyl.